Federal Circuit

D.C. Circuit


Sponsored by:

Heyman IP LLC

Federal Circuit Oral Argument AI Transcripts

The text files below are AI-generated transcripts of oral arguments before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. MP3 recordings of these arguments are publicly hosted on the Federal Circuit's website. Links labeled will direct your browser to those external recordings.

⚠️ These transcripts contain errors, omissions, and inaccuracies

January, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
01/10/2022 21-1701 Carlson v. DVA Whistleblower Protection - Hostile Work Environment and Causation
01/10/2022 21-1866 T.S. v. HHS Procedure - Evidentiary Record and Credibility of Testimony
01/10/2022 21-1968 Stephens v. McDonough Veterans Law - PTSD Claim Regulation Interpretation
01/10/2022 21-2146 Masimo Corporation v. True Wearables, Inc. Trade Secrets - General Knowledge Standard under CUTSA
01/10/2022 21-1367 Slaughter v. McDonough Veterans Law - Harmless Error Analysis in Disability Rating
01/10/2022 21-1838 Modern Font Applications LLC v. Alaska Airlines Procedure - Protective Order Modification and In-House Counsel Access
01/10/2022 21-1936 SEKRI, Inc. v. US Procurement - Mandatory Source Compliance under the JWOD Act
01/11/2022 21-1210 Alaniz v. McDonough Procedure - Harmless Error Analysis in Veterans Claims
01/11/2022 21-1520 Netfuel, Inc. v. Hirshfeld Patents - Obviousness and Claim Construction
01/11/2022 21-1579 Johnson v. Air Force Procedure - Due Process Violations in Employment Termination
01/11/2022 21-2102 Alarm.com Incorporated v. Hirshfeld Procedure - Judicial Review of Ex Parte Reexamination Decisions
01/11/2022 21-1759 Atlanta Gas Light Company v. Bennett Regulator Guards, Inc. Procedure - Mandate Rule and Sanctions Authority
01/11/2022 21-1785 Alexsam, Inc. v. Mastercard International Incorporated Contracts - Covenant Not to Sue and Judicial Estoppel
01/11/2022 21-2369 Nippon Shinyaku Co., Ltd. v. Sarepta Therapeutics, Inc. Contracts - Forum Selection Clause Interpretation
01/11/2022 20-1902 Doe v. US Procedure - Statute of Limitations and Continuing Claims Doctrine
01/12/2022 20-2230 Red Sun Farms v. US Procedure - Jurisdictional Standing
01/12/2022 20-2232 Confederacion de Asociaciones v. US Procedure - Jurisdictional Standing
01/12/2022 20-2265 Bioparques de Occidente v. US Procedure - Jurisdictional Standing
01/12/2022 21-1292 Jem D International (Michigan) v. US Contracts - Duress and Validity of Agreements
01/12/2022 21-1131 Milton v. US Property Rights - Flood Control and Government Takings
01/12/2022 20-2331 Almirall, LLC v. Amneal Pharmaceuticals LLC Patents - Obviousness and Interchangeability of Formulation Components
01/12/2022 21-1183 Cameron International v. Nitro Fluids L.L.C. Patents - Anticipation by Ambiguous Disclosure
01/13/2022 20-2251 Shockwave Medical, Inc. v. Cardiovascular Systems, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Motivation to Combine
01/13/2022 20-2314 Shockwave Medical, Inc. v. Cardiovascular Systems, Inc. Patents - Obviousness and Motivation to Combine References
01/13/2022 21-1166 Raytheon Technologies v. General Electric Company Patents - Claim Construction of “Bond Layer”
01/13/2022 21-1832 Bannister v. DVA Procedure - Burden of Proof in Administrative Review
01/13/2022 21-1443 Hytera Communications Corp. v. Motorola Solutions, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Infringement Standards
01/13/2022 21-1542 SAS Institute, Inc. v. World Programming Limited Copyrights - Non-literal copying and protectability analysis
01/13/2022 21-1552 Filler v. US Procedure - Assignment of Claims Act and Standing
01/13/2022 21-1807 TQ Delta, LLC v. ARRIS Group, Inc. Patents - Motivation to Combine
01/14/2022 21-1045 Smith Montanez v. McDonough Veterans Law - Service-Connected Death Benefits and Regulatory Interpretation
01/14/2022 21-1532 Apple Inc. v. MPH Technologies Oy Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
01/14/2022 21-1896 Bryant v. DVA Procedure - Douglas Factors Consideration
01/14/2022 21-1954 Procon Analytics, LLC v. Spireon, Inc. Patents - Section 101 Eligibility
01/14/2022 20-2008 Broadcom Corporation v. ITC Patents - Domestic Industry Requirement
01/14/2022 21-1260 Renesas Electronics v. Broadcom Corporation Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
01/14/2022 21-1511 Broadcom Corporation v. Renesas Electronics Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
01/14/2022 21-1561 Fleming v. Cirrus Design Corporation Patents - Claim Construction and Indefiniteness
01/27/2022 19-2054 Hologic, Inc. v. Minerva Surgical, Inc. Patents - Estoppel and Claim Scope

February, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
02/07/2022 21-1435 BMW of North America, LLC v. Carrum Technologies, LLC Patents - Obviousness Requirement and Interpretation of Prior Art
02/07/2022 21-1782 Sundbakken v. McDonough Veterans Law - Effective Date for Disability Claims
02/07/2022 21-1056 United Trademark Holdings, Inc v. Disney Enterprises, Inc. Trademarks - Strength of Mark and Likelihood of Confusion
02/07/2022 21-1784 Robinson v. McDonough Procedure - Law of the Case Doctrine and Legal Standards for Agency Decisions
02/07/2022 21-1906 Repifi Vendor Logistics, Inc. v. Intellicentrics, Inc. Patents - Section 101 Eligibility and Inventive Concept
02/07/2022 21-1986 Feiss v. US Procedure - Judicial Review Bar in Payment Eligibility
02/08/2022 21-1749 Lebolo-Watts Constructors v. Secretary of the Army Contracts - Ambiguity in Scope of Work
02/08/2022 21-1799 Barnes v. GSA Procedure - Substantial Evidence for Sick Leave Denial
02/08/2022 21-2086 Hekmati v. US Procedure - Subject Matter Jurisdiction under the Tucker Act
02/08/2022 21-2164 Lowe v. Shieldmark, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Non-Infringement
02/08/2022 20-2092 Intel Corporation v. Qualcomm Incorporated Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
02/08/2022 20-2239 Intel Corporation v. Qualcomm Incorporated Patents - Anticipation and Claim Construction
02/08/2022 20-2240 Intel Corporation v. Qualcomm Incorporated Patents - Anticipation and Claim Construction
02/08/2022 21-1484 Realtime Adaptive Streaming v. Netflix, Inc. Procedure - Prevailing Party Status and Judicial Imprimatur
02/09/2022 20-1350 Zaxcom, Inc. v. Lectrosonics, Inc. Patents - Nexus and Secondary Considerations
02/09/2022 20-1921 Zaxcom, Inc. v. Lectrosonics, Inc. Patents - Obviousness and Nexus Evidence
02/09/2022 21-1908 Travel Sentry, Inc. v. Tropp Patents - Eligibility under Section 101 (Alice Test)
02/09/2022 20-1489 Tetra Tech, Inc. v. US Contracts - Specification Interpretation and Ambiguity
02/09/2022 20-2245 Alphatec Holdings, Inc. v. NuVasive, Inc. Patents - Collateral Estoppel and Obviousness
02/09/2022 21-1726 USP HOLDINGS, INC. v. US Administrative Law - Judicial Review of Executive Action under Section 232
02/09/2022 21-1868 Jeffery v. McDonough Procedure - Appeal Rights Following VA Benefit Award
02/10/2022 19-2211 Taylor v. McDonough Procedure - Right of Access to Benefits
02/11/2022 20-2105 AISG, Inc. v. Secretary of the Army Contracts - Good Faith and Fair Dealing
02/11/2022 21-1618 Ratliff v. McDonough Veterans Law - Harmless Error Analysis and Credibility Determinations
02/11/2022 21-1679 M S International, Inc. v. US Procedure - Scope Modification Authority
02/11/2022 21-1760 Apple Inc. v. Zipit Wireless, Inc. Procedure - Personal Jurisdiction in Patent Disputes
02/11/2022 20-2207 CustomPlay, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc. Patents - Obviousness and Constitutional Challenges
02/11/2022 20-2208 CustomPlay, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Prior Art Disclosure
02/11/2022 20-2209 CustomPlay, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Prior Art Disclosure
02/11/2022 21-2024 Amarin Pharma, Inc. v. Hikma Pharmaceuticals USA Inc. Procedure - Standing for Rule 60 Motion

March, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
03/07/2022 20-2173 Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. v. ITC Trade Dress - Genericness and Secondary Meaning
03/07/2022 21-1601 Ethicon LLC v. Intuitive Surgical, Inc. Patents - Analogous Art and Motivation to Combine
03/07/2022 21-1926 Azurity Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Bionpharma Inc. Patents - Claim Construction of “Buffer”
03/07/2022 21-1939 ImmunoGen, Inc. v. Hirshfeld Patents - Obviousness and Indefiniteness
03/07/2022 20-2278 Modern Font Applications LLC v. Peak Restaurant Partners, LLC Procedure - Venue and Corporate Attribution
03/07/2022 21-1543 Modern Font Applications LLC v. PetSmart, Inc. Patents - Direct and Indirect Infringement Allegations
03/07/2022 21-1870 Willis Electric Co., Ltd. v. Everstar Merchandise Co., Ltd. Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
03/07/2022 21-1882 Everstar Merchandise Co. Ltd. v. Willis Electric Co., Ltd. Patents - Motivation to Combine References
03/08/2022 21-1635 American Patents LLC v. Unified Patents, LLC Procedure - Reviewability of Board's Evidentiary Decisions
03/08/2022 21-1747 Mid Continent Steel & Wire v. US Procedure - Statistical Methodology in Differential Pricing Analysis
03/08/2022 21-2040 VDPP LLC v. VIZIO, Inc. Patents - Indefiniteness and Means-Plus-Function Analysis
03/08/2022 21-2354 Power Probe Group, Inc. v. Innova Electronics Corporation Patents - Claim Construction and Measurement of Continuity
03/08/2022 21-1495 Tris Pharma, Inc. v. Actavis Laboratories FL, Inc. Patents - Obviousness and Motivation to Combine
03/08/2022 21-1775 Boston Scientific v. Nevro Corp. Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
03/08/2022 21-1777 Boston Scientific v. Nevro Corp. Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
03/08/2022 21-1990 Worlds Inc. v. Activision Blizzard Inc. Patents - Abstract Idea and Eligibility
03/09/2022 21-1981 Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH v. Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc. Patents - Analogous Art Misapplication
03/09/2022 21-2074 Semiconductor Connections LLC v. Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co Patents - Claim Construction and Negative Limitations
03/09/2022 20-2102 MobilePay LLC v. Unified Patents, LLC Patents - Written Description and Obviousness
03/09/2022 21-1652 Sommers v. US Procedure - Constructive Filing Doctrine
03/09/2022 21-2013 Littelfuse, Inc. v. Mersen USA EP Corp. Patents - Claim Construction of “Fastening Stem”
03/09/2022 21-1025 O'Keeffe's, Inc. v. Hirshfeld Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
03/10/2022 21-1697 In Re McDonald Patents - Reissue Recapture Rule and Section 101 Amendments
03/10/2022 21-1745 Advanced Voice Recognition v. Apple Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Lexicography
03/10/2022 21-1798 Kennedy v. McDonough Procedure - Delegation of Authority in VA Regulations
03/10/2022 21-2037 LG Electronics Inc. v. ImmerVision, Inc. Patents - Apparent Error Standard
03/10/2022 21-1179 Google LLC v. IPA Technologies Inc. Patents - Inventorship and Burden of Proof
03/10/2022 21-1412 Microsoft Corporation v. IPA Technologies Inc. Patents - Prior Art Public Accessibility
03/10/2022 21-1438 IPA Technologies Inc. v. Google LLC Patents - Reasonable Pertinence and Obviousness
03/11/2022 21-1473 Intuitive Surgical Operations, Inc. v. Auris Health, Inc. Patents - Obviousness - Missing Element Analysis
03/11/2022 21-1732 Auris Health, Inc. v. Intuitive Surgical Operations Patents - Motivation to Combine References
03/11/2022 21-1733 Auris Health, Inc. v. Intuitive Surgical Operations Patents - Obviousness and Claim Construction
03/11/2022 20-1994 Rovi Guides, Inc. v. Hirshfeld Patents - Claim Construction and Causality in Availability Determination
03/11/2022 20-2206 Rovi Guides, Inc. v. Hirshfeld Patents - Obviousness of Multi-Option Media Resumption
03/11/2022 21-1902 In Re Asset Guard Products, Inc. Patents - Analogous Art and Obviousness
03/11/2022 21-1988 Vicentin S.A.I.C. v. US Trade - Anti-Dumping Calculation Adjustments
03/30/2022 18-2140 Arthrex, Inc. v. Smith & Nephew, Inc. Procedure - Appointments Clause and Delegation Authority

April, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
04/04/2022 21-1386 Klipp v. DHS Procedure - Evaluation of Law Enforcement Officer Status
04/04/2022 21-1811 Jordan v. McDonough Procedure - Prejudicial Error Standard in Veterans Claims
04/04/2022 21-2169 Microtechnologies LLC v. United States Attorney General Contracts - Termination for Convenience and Reasonable Charges
04/04/2022 21-1432 Labonte v. US Procedure - Authority to Amend Military Records
04/04/2022 21-1978 Hoist Fitness Systems, Inc. v. TuffStuff Fitness International, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Attorney's Fees
04/04/2022 21-1787 Kluge v. DHS Statutory Interpretation - USERRA Liability of OPM
04/04/2022 21-1888 Centripetal Networks, Inc. v. Cisco Systems, Inc. Procedure - Judicial Recusal and Divestment Interpretation
04/04/2022 21-1989 Mitek Systems, Inc. v. United Services Automobile Association Patents - Declaratory Judgment Standing
04/05/2022 21-1107 Tiger Lily Ventures Ltd. v. Barclays Capital Inc. Trademarks - Abandonment and Likelihood of Confusion
04/05/2022 21-1770 Klein v. OPM Procedure - Survivor Benefits Entitlement
04/05/2022 21-2002 United Access Technologies, LLC v. AT&T Corp. Procedure - Declaratory Judgment Jurisdiction
04/05/2022 21-2089 Webber v. McDonough Veterans Law - Rating Criteria for Diabetes and Peripheral Neuropathy
04/05/2022 21-1547 Zafer Construction Company v. US Procedure - Contract Claims under the FAR
04/05/2022 21-1802 Fairfax v. Army Whistleblower Protection - Protected Disclosure and Causal Connection
04/05/2022 21-1857 Ascion, LLC v. Ashley Furniture Industries, Inc. Patents - Written Description Requirement
04/05/2022 21-1995 Ethicon LLC v. Intuitive Surgical, Inc. Patents - Reasonable Expectation of Success
04/06/2022 21-1932 Meyer Corporation, U.S. v. US Customs - Valuation and Related Party Pricing
04/06/2022 21-2127 Intel Corporation v. XMTT, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and System Operation
04/06/2022 21-2158 Hollymatic Corporation v. Director and CEO Defense Commissary Agency Procurement - Misrepresentation of Product Availability
04/06/2022 20-1941 Billie v. McDonough Procedure - Regulatory Interpretation of 38 CFR 3.156C
04/06/2022 21-1972 AFGE Local 3438 v. SSA Procedure - Associational Standing in Arbitration Appeals
04/06/2022 21-2048 Sure Fit Home Products, LLC v. Maytex Mills, Inc. Patents - Preliminary Injunction and Claim Construction
04/06/2022 21-2161 In Re SawStop Holding LLC Patents - Judicial Authority Over Obviousness-Type Double Patenting Doctrine
04/07/2022 21-1517 ClearOne, Inc. v. Shure Acquisition Holdings Patents - Duty of Disclosure and Indefiniteness
04/07/2022 21-1663 Contemporary Display LLC v. DISH Network L.L.C. Patents - Claim Construction and Administrative Procedure Act Violation
04/07/2022 21-1757 Skaar v. McDonough Procedure - Jurisdictional Requirements for Class Certification in Veterans Court
04/07/2022 21-1940 Koopmans v. McDonough Veterans Law - Presumption of Service Connection and Clear and Unmistakable Error (CUE)
04/07/2022 21-1949 Ethanol Boosting Systems, LLC v. Ford Motor Company Patents - Claim Construction of Fuel Types
04/07/2022 21-1998 Sound View Innovations, LLC v. Hulu, LLC Patents - Claim Construction and Prosecution Disclaimer
04/07/2022 21-2172 California Steel Industries, Inc. v. US Procedure - Intervention Rights in Administrative Tariff Exclusion Process
04/08/2022 20-1259 SynQor, Inc. v. Vicor Corporation Procedure - Mootness and Jurisdictional Standing
04/08/2022 21-1576 Lee v. Google LLC Patents - Waiver of Arguments in IPR Proceedings
04/08/2022 21-1634 Kaufman v. Microsoft Corporation Patents - Claim Construction and Automaticity
04/08/2022 21-1803 GSC Construction, Inc. v. Secretary of the Army Contracts - Interpretation of Scope and Responsibility
04/08/2022 21-1834 PAVO Solutions LLC v. Kingston Technology Company, Inc. Patents - Judicial Correction of Claim Language
04/08/2022 21-2104 SRM Group, Inc. v. Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security Procedure - Burden of Proof in Expert Testimony
04/08/2022 21-2303 Static Media LLC v. Leader Accessories LLC Procedure - Protective Order Violation
04/08/2022 21-1946 Aquila Innovations Inc. v. Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. Patents - Obviousness and Claim Construction
04/19/2022 21-1969 University of Massachusetts v. L'Oreal S.A. Patents - Indefiniteness of Subjective Evaluation Criteria
04/19/2022 21-2081 Groves v. McDonough Procedure - Stay Requests in Veterans' Claims

May, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
05/02/2022 21-1039 SIPCO, LLC v. Emerson Electric Co. Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
05/02/2022 21-1669 Long v. McDonough Veterans Benefits - Causal Link for Functional Impairment
05/02/2022 21-1861 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Bel Fuse Inc. Procedure - Finality of Judgment
05/02/2022 21-1881 Emerson Electric Co. v. SIPCO, LLC Patents - Claim Construction of Scalable Address
05/02/2022 21-1910 Upaid Systems, Ltd. v. Card Concepts, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Non-Infringement
05/02/2022 21-2060 Aspects Furniture International, Inc. v. US Customs - Notice of Liquidation Timing
05/02/2022 21-2098 Coy v. Treasury Procedure - Successive Termination Actions During Pending Appeal
05/02/2022 21-2209 Meenaxi Enterprise, Inc. v. The Coca-Cola Company Trademarks - Territoriality Doctrine and Reputational Injury
05/03/2022 21-2067 Shanxi Hairui Trade Co., Ltd. v. US Procedure - Application of Adverse Facts Available in Administrative Reviews
05/03/2022 21-2101 In Re Intelligent Packaging Pty Limited Patents - Obviousness and Nexus of Secondary Considerations
05/03/2022 21-2174 Pop Top Corp. v. Rakuten Kobo Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Infringement Analysis
05/03/2022 21-2205 Xi'An Metals & Minerals Import & Export Co., Ltd. v. US Procedure - Legislative Rule Validity in Anti-Dumping Context
05/03/2022 20-2334 Cornell Research Foundation, Inc. v. Vidal Patents - Obviousness and Corroboration Standards
05/03/2022 21-1660 Haggart v. US 'Procedure - Attorney's Fees Under the URA'
05/03/2022 21-2093 Finjan LLC v. ESET, LLC Patents - Claim Construction and Indefiniteness
05/04/2022 21-1856 Pulse Electronics, Inc. v. U.D. Electronic Corp. Patents - Inducement of Infringement
05/04/2022 21-1916 Henderson v. McDonough Procedure - Regulatory Interpretation in Veterans Affairs Claims
05/04/2022 21-2112 Wireless Protocol Innovations, Inc. v. TCT Mobile, Inc. Patents - New Theory of Patentability on Remand
05/04/2022 19-2444 New Image Global, Inc. v. US Regulations - Customs Weighing Methodology
05/04/2022 21-1928 Sheppard v. McDonough Procedure - Jurisdictional Notice Requirements in Veterans Claims
05/04/2022 21-2057 LSI Corporation v. Regents of the University of Minnesota Patents - Anticipation and Claim Construction
05/05/2022 20-1976 Implicit, LLC v. NetScout Systems, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction Errors
05/05/2022 20-2210 SPEX Technologies, Inc. v. Apricorn Patents - Claim Construction and Indefiniteness
05/05/2022 21-2125 In Re Apps Patents - Obviousness and Substantial Evidence
05/05/2022 21-1945 Bowling v. McDonough Regulations - Facial Vagueness Challenge
05/05/2022 21-2113 In Re Killian Patents - Subject Matter Eligibility (Mental Processes)
05/05/2022 21-2239 ESIP Series 1, LLC v. doTerra International, LLC Patents - Claim Construction and Infringement Analysis
05/05/2022 21-2281 Shelter Forest International Acquisition, Inc. v. US Procedure - Timeliness of Evidence Submission in Administrative Proceedings
05/06/2022 21-1772 Acqis, LLC v. EMC Corporation Patents - Claim Construction and Intrinsic Evidence
05/06/2022 21-1982 Cellwitch Inc. v. Tile, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
05/06/2022 21-1996 Brown v. GSA Contracts - Interpretation of “Initiate Payment”
05/06/2022 21-2147 NexRF Corp. v. Playtika Ltd. Patents - Eligibility under 35 U.S.C. § 101
05/06/2022 21-1839 Carl Zeiss Meditec, Inc. v. Topcon Medical Systems, Inc. Injunction - Specificity and Scope of Trade Secrets
05/06/2022 21-2084 Best Medical International, Inc. v. Elekta Inc. Patents - Level of Ordinary Skill in the Art
05/06/2022 21-2099 Best Medical International, Inc. v. Elekta Inc. Procedure - Jurisdictional Standing
05/06/2022 21-2176 ARP Materials, Inc. v. US Procedure - Jurisdictional Adequacy of Protest under Section 1581

June, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
06/02/2022 22-1664 Chamberlain Group, LLC v. ITC Procedure - Authority of ITC to Modify Remedial Orders
06/06/2022 21-1629 Hanwha Solutions Corp. v. LONGi Green Energy Technology Co., Ltd. Patents - Claim Construction and Anticipation
06/06/2022 21-2069 TalexMedical, LLC v. Becon Medical Limited Patents - Claim Construction and Substantial Evidence
06/06/2022 21-2133 Memmer v. US Eminent Domain - Causation in Temporary Takings
06/06/2022 21-2032 Morris v. McDonough Procedure - Veterans Court Jurisdiction over Newly Raised Constitutional Claims
06/06/2022 21-2347 Thaler v. Vidal Patents - AI Inventorship
06/06/2022 21-2352 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. v. Dynamics Inc. Patents - Obviousness and Procedural Errors under APA
06/06/2022 21-2374 LAX Electronics, Inc. v. US Procedure - Due Process in Administrative Removal from Qualified Products List
06/07/2022 21-1229 Omni MedSci, Inc. v. Apple Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
06/07/2022 21-2106 Koninklijke Philips N.V. v. Thales USA, Inc. Procedure - Irreparable Harm in ITC Proceedings
06/07/2022 21-2326 Fishermen's Finest, Inc. v. US Property - Takings Clause and Revocability of Fishing Licenses
06/07/2022 21-1973 Cranford v. McDonough Regulatory Interpretation - Veterans Benefits Eligibility
06/07/2022 21-2143 Townsend v. Brooks Sports, Inc. Patents - Obviousness and Claim Construction
06/07/2022 21-2228 Weisner v. Google LLC Patents - Abstract Idea and Eligibility
06/07/2022 21-2350 IBM v. Zillow Group, Inc. Patents - Section 101 Eligibility (Abstract Idea)
06/08/2022 20-1444 C.A. Casyso GmbH v. HemoSonics LLC Patents - Reasonable expectation of success in combination of prior art
06/08/2022 21-1690 Fraternal Order of Police v. Interior Procedure - Jurisdictional Standing
06/08/2022 22-1001 Mosaic Brands, Inc. v. Ridge Wallet LLC Patents - Inequitable Conduct and Appealability of Summary Judgment Denial
06/08/2022 22-1042 In Re Advanced Nutritional Supplements Trademarks - Merely Descriptive vs. Suggestive Distinction
06/08/2022 21-1041 WorldSource Enterprises, LLC v. Vidal Patents - Translation Accuracy and Certification Issues
06/08/2022 21-2138 Sonova AG v. MED-EL Elektromedizinische Gerate GmbH Patents - Obviousness of Diametric Magnetization in Cochlear Implants
06/08/2022 21-2222 A. O. Smith Corporation v. Bradford White Corporation Patents - Claim Construction of “Natural Convection” and “Dropping Limitation”
06/08/2022 22-1021 Committee Overseeing Action for Lumber v. US Procedure - Authority to Issue Regulations Under International Trade Agreements
06/09/2022 20-2281 Comcast Cable Communications, LLC v. Realtime Adaptive Streaming LLC Patents - Obviousness and Theory of Combination
06/09/2022 21-1030 American National v. Sleep Number Corporation Patents - Claim Construction Ambiguity
06/09/2022 21-1321 American National v. Sleep Number Corporation Patents - Obviousness and Burden of Proof
06/09/2022 21-1545 Google LLC v. Realtime Adaptive Streaming Patents - Obviousness and APA Violations
06/09/2022 21-1878 Burns v. McDonough Procedure - Spoliation of Evidence and Apparent Entitlement to Benefits
06/09/2022 21-2272 U.S. Aeroteam, Inc. v. US Contracts - Constructive Change and Cardinal Change
06/09/2022 22-1016 Click-to-Call Technologies, LP v. Ingenio, Inc. IPR Estoppel - Scope of Grounds Raised
06/10/2022 21-1605 NuCurrent, Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Patents - Written Description and Obviousness
06/10/2022 21-1840 NuCurrent, Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Patents - Anticipation and Claim Construction
06/10/2022 21-2244 Plastipak Packaging, Inc. v. Premium Waters, Inc. Patents - Inventorship Dispute
06/10/2022 21-2312 Hyundai Electric & Energy Systems v. US Procedure - Adverse Facts Available
06/10/2022 19-2454 McIntosh v. Defense Appointments Clause - Status of Administrative Judges
06/10/2022 21-1931 Netflix, Inc. v. DivX, LLC Patents - Claim Construction of “Level of Detail”
06/10/2022 21-2289 Innovative Global Systems, LLC v. Motive Technologies, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
06/10/2022 22-1027 CareDx, Inc. v. Natera, Inc. Patents - Patent Eligibility of Measurement Methods for Natural Phenomena
06/21/2022 22-145 In Re Palo Alto Networks, Inc. unknown Patents – Appointments Clause Challenge to Director's Supervision of Institution Decisions

July, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
07/05/2022 21-1537 SawStop Holding LLC v. Vidal Patents - Patent Term Adjustment Eligibility
07/05/2022 21-2095 Doyon v. US Procedure - Application of Liberal Consideration in Discharge Review
07/05/2022 21-2191 CoolTVNetwork.com, Inc. v. Blackboard, Inc. Patents - Indefiniteness and Algorithm Disclosure under 112.6
07/05/2022 22-1026 In Re Zahner Design Group, Ltd. Patents - Disclosure of Design Embodiment
07/05/2022 21-1917 Polaris Innovations Limited v. Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction of “Checksum”
07/05/2022 21-1965 Supreme Foodservice GmbH v. Director of the Defense Logistics Agency Contracts - First Material Breach and Waiver Defense
07/05/2022 21-2077 Carter v. McDonough Statutory Interpretation - Willful Misconduct and Causation in Veterans Benefits
07/05/2022 21-2111 Innovation Sciences, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc. Patents - Written Description Requirement
07/06/2022 21-1974 Hanser v. McDonough Regulatory Interpretation - Definition vs. Guideline in Disability Evaluations
07/06/2022 21-2008 Avalos v. US Labor Law - FLSA Compliance During Government Shutdowns
07/06/2022 21-2021 Abrantes v. US Labor Law - FLSA Compliance During Government Shutdowns
07/06/2022 21-2163 Hirsch v. US Statutory Interpretation - Mandatory Retirement Date Exclusion
07/06/2022 21-2167 Cooperative Entertainment, Inc. v. Kollective Technology, Inc. Patents - Eligibility under Alice/Mayo Framework
07/06/2022 21-2255 Martin v. US Labor Law - FLSA Prompt Payment vs. Anti-Deficiency Act Compliance
07/06/2022 21-2274 Trusted Knight Corporation v. IBM Patents - Obviousness and Motivation to Combine References
07/06/2022 22-1075 Johnson Investors Limited Partnership v. United States Postmaster Gene Lease Disputes - Maintenance Obligations and Capital Improvements
07/07/2022 21-1459 Sullivan v. McDonough Veterans Law - Presumption of Soundness and Evidentiary Burden
07/07/2022 21-1794 Dionex Softron GmbH v. Agilent Technologies, Inc. Patents - Corroboration Requirement for Reduction to Practice
07/07/2022 21-1904 Davis v. McDonough Procedure - Veterans Court's Authority to Interpret Regulations
07/07/2022 21-1937 Vocalife LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc. Patents - Literal Infringement and Claim Construction
07/07/2022 21-2275 Personalized Media Communications, LLC v. Apple Inc. Patents - Prosecution Laches
07/07/2022 21-2324 Hyatt v. PTO Patents - PTO's Authority to Impose Restriction Requirements
07/07/2022 21-2342 Par Pharmaceutical, Inc. v. Eagle Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Patents - Declaratory Judgment and Infringement Analysis in ANDA Litigation
07/07/2022 21-2372 Dionex Softron GmbH v. Agilent Technologies, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Written Description

August, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
08/01/2022 19-1483 Polaris Innovations Limited v. Hirshfeld Patents - Claim Construction of “Resource Tag Buffer”
08/01/2022 19-1484 Polaris Innovations Limited v. Hirshfeld Procedure - Agency Inaction on Joint Motion to Terminate IPR
08/01/2022 21-1903 Nike, Inc. v. Adidas AG Patents - Burden of Persuasion in IPR Proceedings
08/01/2022 21-1967 Arendi S.A.R.L. v. LG Electronics Inc. Patents - Claim Splitting and Procedural Violation
08/02/2022 21-1900 VR Optics, LLC v. Peloton Interactive, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Summary Judgment
08/02/2022 21-2064 Philips North America, LLC v. ITC Patents - Eligibility and Anticipation
08/02/2022 21-2121 Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc. v. Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp. Patents - Anticipation and Obviousness
08/02/2022 22-1171 Treehouse Avatar LLC v. Valve Corporation Procedure - Expert Testimony Admissibility
08/03/2022 21-1488 American Federation v. Air Force Procedure - Substitution of Party in Appeal
08/03/2022 21-1851 Provisur Technologies, Inc. v. Weber, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Substantial Evidence
08/03/2022 21-1883 Provisur Technologies, Inc. v. Weber, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction of “Select Differential Speeds”
08/03/2022 21-1942 Provisur Technologies, Inc. v. Weber, Inc. Patents - Substantial Evidence and Claim Limitation Analysis
08/04/2022 21-2173 Sanderling Management Ltd. v. Snap Inc. Patents - Eligibility under Section 101
08/04/2022 21-2208 Philanthropist.com, Inc. v. General Conference Corp. of Seventh-Day Ad Trademarks - Standing to Cancel Registration
08/04/2022 21-2370 Grace Instrument Industries, LLC v. Chandler Instruments Company, LLC Patents - Claim Construction and Indefiniteness
08/04/2022 22-1197 Doe v. Biden Firearms - Authority to Implement Amnesty for Unregistered Machine Guns

September, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
09/06/2022 20-1842 Seneca v. MSPB Procedure - Jurisdictional Authority of MSPB Over Suitability Determinations
09/06/2022 21-1498 Uniloc 2017 LLC v. Google LLC Patents - Standing and License Termination
09/06/2022 21-1555 Uniloc USA, Inc. v. Motorola Mobility LLC Patents - Issue Preclusion and Waiver
09/06/2022 21-1795 Uniloc 2017 LLC v. Blackboard Inc. Patents - Article III Standing
09/06/2022 21-2039 Microsoft Corporation v. Uniloc 2017 LLC Patents - Compatibility Check and Claim Interpretation
09/06/2022 22-1145 Seoul Viosys Co., Ltd. v. P3 International Corporation Patents - On-Sale Bar and Infringement Allegations
09/06/2022 22-1167 Panduit Corp. v. Corning Incorporated Patents - Claim Construction of “Choosing for Use”
09/07/2022 21-2150 ABC Corporation I v. Partnership and Unincorporated Associations Procedure - Due Process in Preliminary Injunction Enforcement
09/07/2022 21-2159 Cap Export, LLC v. Zinus, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Anticipation
09/07/2022 21-2277 ABC Corporation I v. Partnership and Unincorporated Associations Procedure - Ex Parte Preliminary Injunction Validity
09/07/2022 22-1081 WiNet Labs LLC v. Motorola Mobility LLC Procedure - Subject Matter Jurisdiction and Standing
09/08/2022 20-2271 VirnetX Inc. v. Mangrove Partners Master Fund Patents - Claim Construction and Direct Communication
09/08/2022 21-1672 VirnetX Inc. v. Apple Inc. Patents - Damages Apportionment and Expert Testimony Reliability
09/08/2022 21-2330 Lal v. HHS Procedure - Misrepresentation of Material Facts in Investigation
09/08/2022 22-1092 Adasa Inc. v. Avery Dennison Corporation Patents - Section 101 Eligibility

October, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
10/03/2022 21-2184 Novozymes North America, Inc. v. Danisco US Inc. Patents - Anticipation and Claim Construction
10/03/2022 21-2246 Minerva Surgical, Inc. v. Hologic, Inc. Patents - Ready for Patenting Requirement
10/03/2022 22-1227 Philip Morris Products S.A. v. ITC Procedure - Statutory Consultation Requirement
10/03/2022 20-2059 CUPP Computing AS v. Trend Micro Inc. Patents - Claim Construction of “Implemented”
10/03/2022 20-2237 Trend Micro Inc. v. CUPP Computing AS Patents - Claim Construction and Substantial Evidence
10/03/2022 20-2262 CUPP Computing AS v. Trend Micro Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Prosecution Disclaimer
10/04/2022 21-2282 Scepter Canada, Inc. v. No Spill, LLC Patents - Obviousness and Substantial Evidence
10/04/2022 21-2311 SoClean, Inc. v. Sunset Healthcare Solutions, Inc. Trade Dress - Secondary Meaning and Functionality
10/04/2022 22-1140 Bridges v. US Labor Law - Compensability of Travel Time for Voluntary Overtime
10/04/2022 22-1595 Genentech, Inc. v. Sandoz Inc. Patents - Inducement of Infringement
10/04/2022 21-1924 UCB, Inc. v. Actavis Laboratories UT, Inc. Patents - Obviousness and Anticipation of Overlapping Ranges
10/04/2022 21-2088 Penley v. McDonough Veterans Law - Implicit Denial of TDIU Claim
10/04/2022 21-2218 Google LLC v. Hammond Development International, Inc. Patents - Collateral Estoppel and Claim Validity
10/04/2022 21-2349 Infernal Technology, LLC v. Activision Blizzard Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Infringement
10/05/2022 21-1836 Obsidian Solutions Group, LLC v. US Statutory Interpretation - Applicability of the Runway Extension Act to the SBA
10/05/2022 21-2319 Tubular Rollers, LLC v. Maximus Oilfield Products, LLC Patents - Claim Construction of “Parallel” and “Collinear”
10/05/2022 22-1274 In Re Janke Procedure - Supreme Court Precedent Binding Effect
10/06/2022 20-1637 Rudisill v. McDonough Statutory Interpretation - Education Benefits Eligibility
10/07/2022 21-1762 Intel Corporation v. VLSI Technology LLC Patents - Obviousness and Claim Construction
10/07/2022 21-1826 VLSI Technology LLC v. Intel Corporation Patents - Claim Construction and Electrical Interconnection
10/07/2022 21-2001 Edenfield v. DVA Whistleblower Protection - Reasonable Belief of Violation
10/07/2022 21-2270 Pharmacyclics LLC v. Alvogen, Inc. Patents - Written Description and Obviousness
10/07/2022 20-1947 Cellspin Soft, Inc. v. Canon U.S.A., Inc. Patents - Claim Construction of “Paired Wireless Connection”
10/07/2022 20-1948 Cellspin Soft, Inc. v. Panasonic Corporation Patents - Claim Construction and Prior Art Analysis
10/07/2022 21-2278 Frick v. McDonough Veterans Law - Clear and Unmistakable Error (CUE) in Presumption of Aggravation Claims
10/07/2022 22-1059 Neuroptics, Inc. v. Brightlamp, Inc. Contracts - Definiteness of Settlement Agreement

November, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
11/01/2022 22-1211 In Re Yu Patents - Claim Scope and Construction
11/01/2022 22-1394 Arius Two, Inc. v. Alvogen PB Research & Development LLC Patents - Obviousness and Inherency
11/01/2022 21-2187 Roane v. McDonough Veterans Law - Interpretation of Benefit of the Doubt Standard
11/01/2022 22-1275 22nd Century Technologies, Inc. v. US Procurement - Jurisdictional Authority Over Size Protests
11/01/2022 20-1319 Signature Systems, LLC v. American Express Company Patents - Abstract Idea Determination
11/01/2022 21-1849 Ideker Farms, Inc. v. US Eminent Domain - Causation and Reasonable Expectations in Takings Claims
11/01/2022 21-2304 Secretary of Defense v. Raytheon Company Procedure - Record-Keeping Compliance for Allowable Costs
11/02/2022 21-1595 Amp Plus, Inc. v. DMF, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
11/02/2022 21-2171 Gudinas v. McDonough Veterans Law - Assessment of New and Material Evidence under 38 CFR 3.156b
11/02/2022 21-2216 Rueter v. Commerce Procedure - Ex Parte Communications and Due Process
11/02/2022 22-1308 Trinity Info Media, LLC v. Covalent, Inc. Patents - Section 101 Invalidity (Abstract Idea)
11/02/2022 21-2035 Carmazzi Global Solutions, Inc. v. Commissioner of Social Security Procedure - Jurisdictional Filing Requirements
11/02/2022 22-1080 Calapristi v. US Contracts - Government Privity and Implied Obligations
11/02/2022 22-1231 Carmazzi Global Solutions, Inc. v. Commissioner of Social Security Procedure - Jurisdictional Filing Requirements
11/02/2022 21-2085 Uniloc 2017 LLC. v. Netflix, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Specification Support
11/02/2022 22-1033 Blazer v. Best Bee Brothers LLC Patents - Claim Construction and Non-Infringement
11/02/2022 22-1161 Acquisition 362, LLC v. US Procedure - Jurisdictional Standing and Suspension of Liquidation
11/02/2022 22-1277 Behrens v. US Easements - Scope of Use and Railroad Purposes
11/03/2022 21-2142 Norris v. Commerce Employment Law - Medical Inability to Perform Duties
11/03/2022 21-2310 Intelligent Investments, Inc. v. US Procedure - Discovery Compliance and Health-Related Delays
11/03/2022 21-2327 In Re One Love Brewery, LLC Trademarks - Likelihood of confusion
11/03/2022 22-1012 In Re Google LLC Patents - Obviousness and Factual Support for Prior Art Findings
11/03/2022 22-1077 Pokarna Engineered Stone Limited v. US Trade - Definition of Domestic Producers
11/03/2022 22-1314 Jackson v. McDonough Veterans Law - Compliance with Remand Order
11/03/2022 21-1992 Universal Electronics, Inc. v. Roku, Inc. Patents - Motivation to Combine References
11/03/2022 21-2128 Universal Electronics, Inc. v. Roku, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Prior Art Disclosure
11/03/2022 22-1058 Roku, Inc. v. Universal Electronics, Inc. Patents - Obviousness of Communication Methods
11/03/2022 22-1365 Kelly v. US Military Retirement - Property Interest and Due Process
11/03/2022 21-2340 Midwest Athletics and Sports Alliance LLC v. Ricoh USA, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Indefiniteness
11/04/2022 20-1183 Arbutus Biopharma Corporation v. ModernaTX, Inc. Patents - Inherent Anticipation
11/04/2022 21-1976 Silva v. McDonough Veterans Law - Appeal Process and Claim Reopening
11/04/2022 21-2241 Sig Sauer Inc. v. NST Global, LLC Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
11/04/2022 22-1318 Tippmann Engineering, LLC v. Innovative Refrigeration Systems, Inc. Patents - Claim Construction and Written Description Support
11/04/2022 21-2225 Van Dermark v. McDonough Procedure - Statutory Interpretation of Reimbursement Provisions
11/07/2022 20-1965 Chamberlain Group, Inc. v. ITC Patents - Claim Construction and Infringement
11/07/2022 21-2175 Mattox v. McDonough Procedure - Applicability of AMA Notice Provisions to Legacy Claims
11/07/2022 21-2320 Salazar v. AT&T Mobility LLC Patents - Claim Construction of “Microprocessor”
11/07/2022 22-1029 AlterWAN, Inc. v. Unified Patents, LLC Patents - Substantial Evidence for Claim Construction
11/07/2022 21-2221 Moghadam v. DVA Whistleblower Protection - Jurisdiction and Corrective Action
11/16/2022 21-1764 Virentem Ventures, LLC v. Google LLC Patents - Claim Construction and Validity Based on Time Scale Modification
11/16/2022 21-1934 Virentem Ventures, LLC v. Google LLC Patents - Claim Construction of “Media Work”
11/16/2022 21-1805 Virentem Ventures, LLC v. Google LLC Patents - Claim Construction of Time Scale Modification

December, 2022

Date Docket MP3 Transcript Topic
12/05/2022 21-2203 Blix Inc. v. Apple Inc. Antitrust - Monopoly Maintenance through Exclusionary Conduct
12/05/2022 21-2211 SynQor, Inc. v. Vicor Corporation Patents - Issue Preclusion and Obviousness
12/05/2022 21-2296 Ironburg Inventions Ltd. v. Valve Corporation Patents - Indefiniteness of Claim Language
12/05/2022 21-2301 Bertini v. Apple Inc. Trademarks - Tacking Doctrine and Scope of Goods/Services
12/05/2022 21-2329 Thornton v. McDonough Statutory Interpretation - Application of Benefit of the Doubt Rule
12/05/2022 21-2348 LKQ Corporation v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC Patents - Design Patent Obviousness Analysis
12/05/2022 22-1018 Health Republic Insurance Company v. US Class Actions - Attorney Fee Reasonableness and Lodestar Cross-Check
12/05/2022 22-1253 LKQ Corporation v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC Patents - Ordinary Observer Test for Design Patent Anticipation
12/06/2022 18-1831 Polaris Innovations Limited v. US Patents - Claim Construction and Obviousness
12/06/2022 22-1137 In Re Roche Diabetes Care, Inc. Patents - Obviousness and Burden of Proof
12/06/2022 22-1201 Stimson Lumber Company v. US Easements - Scope and Purpose Limitations
12/06/2022 22-1878 Astellas US LLC v. Hospira, Inc. Procedure - Supplemental Infringement Contentions
12/06/2022 21-2023 Cooper v. McDonough Statutory Interpretation - Definition of “Donation” in Veterans Benefits
12/06/2022 22-1116 ChromaDex, Inc. v. Elysium Health, Inc. Patents - Section 101 Patent Eligibility
12/06/2022 22-1210 Michael Johnson Logging v. Secretary of Agriculture Contracts - Breach of Duty of Good Faith and Fair Dealing
12/06/2022 22-1244 In Re Bodo Patents - Obviousness and Motivation to Combine References
12/07/2022 21-2253 Finjan, LLC v. Juniper Networks, Inc. Procedure - Attorney's Fees Apportionment
12/07/2022 22-1037 Intel Corporation v. PACT XPP Schweiz AG Patents - Obviousness and Motivation to Combine
12/07/2022 22-1038 Intel Corporation v. PACT XPP Schweiz AG Patents - Claim Construction and Motivation to Combine
12/07/2022 22-1102 P Tech, LLC v. Intuitive Surgical, Inc. Patents - Motivation to Combine References
12/07/2022 22-1139 Intel Corporation v. PACT XPP Schweiz AG Patents - Claim Construction Inconsistency
12/07/2022 22-1326 USADATA Incorporated v. DataWidget LLC Patents - Abstract Idea and Inventive Concept
12/07/2022 22-1472 E&I Global Energy Services, Inc. v. US Contracts - Termination for Default and Good Faith Obligations
12/08/2022 21-2030 Crews v. McDonough Procedure - Substituted Claimant Rights under 38 USC 5121A
12/08/2022 21-2269 In Re University of Notre Dame Patents - Obviousness and Substantial Evidence
12/08/2022 22-1035 Lockheed Martin Aeronautics Company v. Secretary of the Air Force Contracts - Government Claim vs. Contractor Claim
12/08/2022 22-1601 Swift & Staley, Inc. v. US Procedure - Affiliation through Negative Control
12/09/2022 21-1662 Adams v. US Hazardous Duty Pay - Exposure to Virulent Biologicals

User Tools